A quote from Rick Brewster (Claude vibe-coded a Direct2D clean-room rewrite for Paint.NET on WINE)
- ID: cd5da196
- 原文链接: https://simonwillison.net/2026/Sep/2/rick-brewster
- 作者: Simon Willison (quoting Rick Brewster)
- 日期: 2026-09-02
- 抓取时间: 2026-09-02T15:31:00Z
- 分类: coding
- 来源类型: article
- 语言: zh
- 标签: vibe-coding, windows, wine, direct2d, agent-limits
- 质量评分: 4/5
中文导读
Simon Willison 9 月 2 日转引 Paint.NET 作者 Rick Brewster 的自述：Direct2D 一直是 Paint.NET 跑在 WINE 上最大的拦路虎，而 WINE 永远不会完成得够用Brewster 让 Claude 用一份内部 DLLPaintDotNet.Windows.Direct2D1.Managed.dllclean-room 逆向重写了一套 Direct2D，由 /wine 触发；代价是 18 万行 "vibe-coded" 代码，他本人明确表示不可能逐行 review（Paint.NET 其他 70 万行他盯了 20 年）他同时给出 agent 在真实 C++/Windows 图形栈里的失败模式：COM 的 AddRef 引用计数必须人盯架构决策要"拍两巴掌"才能拉回来，倒是 Direct2D 内置效果库里的数学公式 Claude 自己逆完了这是 vibe coding 在大型系统级工程里最具体的一份作者自述，"代码量大到我读不完"+"失败集中在资源管理与架构"是 agent 工程里长期没解决的边界条件
一句话点评
Simon Willison 9 月 2 日转引 Paint.
English Abstract / Summary
Simon Willison relays Paint.NET author Rick Brewster's account of using Claude to clean-room reimplement Direct2D so the editor can run on WINE; the result is 180,000 lines of "vibe-coded" C# that Brewster says he cannot review line-by-line (Paint.NET's other 700K lines he has shepherded for 20 years). Brewster documents Claude's failure modes on real Windows/C++ system code: COM AddRef reference counts need human oversight, architectural decisions need to be "slapped down," but the math inside Direct2D's built-in effect library Claude reverse-engineered on its own. The piece is the most concrete author-side account of vibe coding in a large system-level codebase.
Obsidian Notes
- 由
daily-intake-evening2026-09-02 cron 从当日 Obsidian 摘要（论文流水线 / AK-RSS / ClawFeed / X 书签消化）发现并入库存量阶段。 - 中文导读与判断均锚定在条目已有摘要、源页面正文、作者、日期与分类信息；未补充源页面之外的实验细节。